Four Roses Barrel Strength Single Barrel OESV Shelf Review

Shelf Review
Designed to give you all the quick hit information you need when you’re standing in front of your local liquor store’s whisky shelf.

Four Roses hasn’t done a great job differentiating their single barrel products. On the one hand, you have the 100 proof, standard issue single barrel that is around $40 and always uses Four Roses’s OBSV recipe. On the other, you have specifically selected, barrel strength picks of their single barrel that come in almost the exact same bottle and packaging – with the biggest differences being “private select” on the neck label, and a gold foil label on the front. This clearly isn’t enough of a difference as when posting this exact bottle on social media, with the price I paid for it ($79.99) I was hit with a lot of comments saying they could find it in their local store for around $40. That is assuredly not the case, as these special barrel strength private select picks are bottled at full cask strength and can feature any of the 10 recipes from Four Roses.

In this case, we have an OESV picked by Whole Foods in Southern California and was aged 9 years and 11 months. Coming in at 58.9% ABV, let’s see if this is worth double the price of the standard single barrel!

Age: 9 years 11 months

ABV: 58.9%

Cask: Virgin oak

MSRP: $79.99

Distillery Name: Four Roses

Review Date: 5/1/23

 

Nose: Wood, graham crackers, vanilla marshmallow, light green apple, and tart melon. Big, fruity, sweet nose.

 Palate: Deep caramel sweetness, with orange chocolate, apple peel, and woody baritone notes. Viscous mouthfeel with a thick, syrupy character and a well restrained heat.

Finish: Long finish with a minty freshness. Traditional sweet, caramels, brown sugar, and dark chocolate with a touch of pepper. Like a Mexican hot chocolate that lingers for a long time.  

Score: 93

Would I buy again? At $79.99, these Four Roses Barrel Strength picks are an instant buy for me. It’s a shame that many stores now have them closer to $100+ or as part of a bundle to help sell less desirable products. And while I still find it hard to pinpoint a “Four Roses style” with its plethora of recipes and mashbills, it’s hard to deny that they do make incredible bourbon. This OESV choice is fruity, woody, and full of nuance. And I have to hand it to Four Roses for making these barrel strength picks a lot more available than the equivalents from Buffalo Trace. If you do happen to find one of these barrel strength private picks, they are easily worth a try.

 

Previous
Previous

Fox and Oden Single Malt Review

Next
Next

Jim Beam Devil’s Cut Shelf Review