Benromach 2007 Cask Strength Batch 1 Review

Shelf Review

Designed to give you all the quick hit information you need when you’re standing in front of your local liquor store’s whisky shelf.

Before I found this bottle on sale at K&L earlier this year, I had never tried anything from Benromach. Their traditional bottle design always left a bit to be desired for me and I normally found myself passing over them for a Glendronach 12 or a more classic Speysider. But after stopping to take a look at the specs on this bottle, I couldn’t resist picking it up. Distilled in 2007 and bottled way back in 2018, this cask strength Benromach boasts no chill filtration and completely natural color. Clocking in at 58.2% ABV, this whiskey won’t be for the faint of heart.

Age: 11 year

ABV: 58.2%

Cask: First fill sherry and bourbon casks

MSRP: $90

Distillery Name: Benromach Distillery

Review Date: 6/9/22

Nose: Sweet peat, soft ash, a sugared smoke meat - almost like the maple glaze on Thanksgiving turkey, but instead used on bacon. Lemongrass and toasted bark mingles with the smell of a freshly put out campfire.

Palate: Surprisingly less peat on the palate than the nose. Instead, there is a funky malt note wrapped up in a hint of Traeger smoke. Sweeter than I expected, but similar to licking old leather (but in a good way!) The mouthfeel is excellent. Full bodied and toasty, the heat is well contained – even at 58%. This is lip-smacking good – with less peat than I initially expected.  

Finish: Long, warming finish with notes of honey, bitter tobacco, and slightly briny peat (almost like soggy burned log). There’s heat here, but never feels spicy.

 

Score: 93 

Would I buy again? In a word – absolutely. This is a delicious pour; and may have become one of my favorite peated whiskies. Full disclosure, this bottle has been open about a month and I do feel that it’s gotten gentler with time and opened up to reveal more sweet and malty notes than my initial pours (which felt a little peat dominate). Even at the full MSRP, this is an excellent younger cask strength scotch that is a hell of an introduction to the Benromach distillery.  If you see one of these languishing on your local store’s shelf, go and rescue it! Thank me later.

Previous
Previous

Dalmore 15 Year Review

Next
Next

The Glenrothes 1998 Review